Motortopia: Where your passion parks

Motortopia: Where your passion parks.

Why Join Motortopia? So you can post comments on... Forums! Photos! Vehicles! Garages! Journals! Events!

  1. cars
  2. bikes
  3. boats
  4. planes

Cars > thejudge’s Garage > Blog > where it all started and why if in a hurry just read bold type and go to 6 minute mark on video then ask yourself why didn't the media tell us?

 

thejudge’s Profile Photo

thejudge

M –62
Vidalia, Louisiana
United States

 

Advertisement

Advertisement

where it all started and why if in a hurry just read bold type and go to 6 minute mark on video then ask yourself why didn't the media tell us?

By thejudge

Court vacates part of Katrina insurance case award
AP
By MICHAEL KUNZELMAN, Associated Press Writer Michael Kunzelman, Associated Press Writer – Thu Mar 12 2008, 3:36 pm ET

NEW ORLEANS – Jurors shouldn't have awarded money to a south Louisiana couple for their allegation that an insurance company acted in bad faith when it denied their homeowner claim after Hurricane Katrina, a federal appeals court has ruled.


Wednesday's ruling by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals vacates a portion of a November 2007 judgment against State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. that awarded Michael and Judy Kodrin roughly $356,000 in damages and penalties, plus attorney fees. Their trial was the first in Louisiana against State Farm over damage from the August 2005 hurricane.

A three-judge panel from the 5th Circuit said the Kodrins weren't entitled to bad-faith penalties, damages or attorney fees because the couple failed to prove State Farm had no justification for denying their claim. The panel instructed U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier to recalculate the award based on its ruling.

"We felt all along our claim handling was in good faith, and the 5th Circuit's ruling has affirmed that," State Farm spokesman Jeff McCollum said in a statement.

State Farm says its homeowner policies cover damage from a hurricane's wind but not its rising water, and the Bloomington, Ill.-based insurer concluded that Katrina's flood waters demolished the couple's Port Sulphur home.

The appeals court upheld a jury's decision that State Farm owed the couple about $200,000 for Katrina's wind damage.

But the 5th Circuit said the only evidence of bad faith presented by the Kodrins was State Farm's denial and their expert's testimony that wind caused the damage.

"This is evidence that State Farm was wrong about the cause of damage, but without more, it is not evidence of bad faith," the judges wrote.

The Kodrins, they continued, "essentially ask this court to find bad faith any time an insurer denies coverage and a jury disagrees. This would unduly pressure insurers to pay out claims that they have reason to believe lie outside the scope of coverage, solely to avoid penalties later."

John Redmann, a lawyer for the Kodrins, said the ruling could cost his clients up to about $250,000 that jurors and Barbier had awarded for penalties, mental anguish and attorneys' fees.

"Felt like I got punched in my stomach. So did my clients," he said.


Redmann said he is weighing his clients' legal options, including asking the 5th Circuit to rehear the case.

"We just believe the court has taken a big step backward in the rights of insurance victims," he added.

Log in to post comments.

Read comments on this blog post 1 – 3 of 3

camaro1093ac’s Profile Photo
camaro1093ac
Apr 13, 2009 at 8:43 pm
Well if they had wind damage then the water could get in as rain and ruin everything inside so they should pay up. Where the wind goes so goes the rain.
 
chevy66babe’s Profile Photo
chevy66babe
Apr 8, 2009 at 10:08 am
That's so wrong. My cousin lives in central Fla and she just got word that State Farm is no longer insuring any houses in Fla, so she has to get new ins and pay more. She's not rated as being in hurricane zone, but State Farm said across the board for Fla.
 
FriedGreenTMater’s Profile Photo
FriedGreenTMate
r
Apr 8, 2009 at 8:36 am
aren't hurricanes all about wind? If not for the wind the water would stay in the ocean.
 

view more

Download Drive Magazine Now!

Advertisements

Advertisements

    Special Offers & Deals

Advertisement

 

Cars > thejudge’s Garage > Blog > where it all started and why if in a hurry just read bold type and go to 6 minute mark on video then ask yourself why didn't the media tell us?

Print your passion at Motortopia.com (http://www.motortopia.com)